Worth the replay?

Saturday, September 23's games ranked by how good they turned out to be: late drama, comebacks, lead swaps and overtime. No scores, no winners, so you can decide what to watch without spoilers.

Best games of the season →

Get the weekend's best games every Friday. Free, one email a week.

  1. #1
    Ohio StateatNotre Dame
    CFB· NBCDown to the wireBig comeback
    A+
    91/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings25/25
    Comeback18/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 93 × pre-game weight 0.97 (pre-game Watchability 95, estimated) = 91

  2. #2
    Florida StatClemson
    CFB· ABCOvertimeDown to the wireBig comeback
    A
    77/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings21/25
    Comeback15/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth5/10
    Overtime+8

    Drama 93 × pre-game weight 0.82 (pre-game Watchability 65, estimated) = 77

  3. #3
    AkronatIndiana
    CFB· BTNOvertimeDown to the wireBig comeback
    B+
    70/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings25/25
    Comeback15/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth8/10
    Overtime+8

    Drama 100 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 70

  4. #4
    MinnesotaatNorthwestern
    CFB· BTNOvertimeDown to the wireBig comeback
    B+
    69/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings23/25
    Comeback20/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth3/10
    Overtime+8

    Drama 98 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 69

  5. #5
    C MichiganatSouth Alabama
    CFB· ESPN+Down to the wireBig comeback
    B+
    66/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings25/25
    Comeback17/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth8/10

    Drama 95 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 66

  6. #6
    New MexicoatUMass
    CFB· ESPN+OvertimeDown to the wire
    B
    59/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings20/25
    Comeback8/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth3/10
    Overtime+8

    Drama 84 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 59

  7. #7
    New Mexico StatHawai'i
    CFBDown to the wireBig comeback
    B
    59/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings20/25
    Comeback14/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 84 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 59

  8. #8
    ArkansasatLSU
    CFB· ESPNDown to the wireBack and forth
    B
    58/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings15/25
    Comeback4/20
    Decided late12/15
    Back-and-forth10/10

    Drama 71 × pre-game weight 0.82 (pre-game Watchability 65, estimated) = 58

  9. #9
    App StateatWyoming
    CFB· CBSSNBig comeback
    B
    57/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension18/30
    Swings22/25
    Comeback18/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth8/10

    Drama 82 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 57

  10. #10
    ArizonaatStanford
    CFB· PACNDown to the wireBack and forth
    C+
    54/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings18/25
    Comeback7/20
    Decided late13/15
    Back-and-forth10/10

    Drama 78 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 54

  11. #11
    Southern MissatArkansas St
    CFB· ESPN+Down to the wire
    C+
    53/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings19/25
    Comeback9/20
    Decided late12/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 75 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 53

  12. #12
    James MadisonatUtah State
    CFBDown to the wire
    C+
    49/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings21/25
    Comeback4/20
    Decided late12/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 70 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 49

  13. #13
    Texas TechatWest Virginia
    CFB· BIG12|ESPN+
    C+
    49/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings15/25
    Comeback7/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 70 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 49

  14. #14
    UNLVatUTEP
    CFB· ESPN+Down to the wire
    C+
    49/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings19/25
    Comeback0/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 69 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 49

  15. #15
    Kennesaw StatTennessee Tech
    CFB· ESPN+Down to the wire
    C+
    48/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings18/25
    Comeback10/20
    Decided late8/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 69 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 48

  16. #16
    TulsaatN Illinois
    CFB· CBSSN
    C+
    48/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension27/30
    Swings20/25
    Comeback11/20
    Decided late5/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 68 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 48

  17. #17
    Georgia TechatWake Forest
    CFB· CW
    C
    45/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension28/30
    Swings15/25
    Comeback7/20
    Decided late12/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 64 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 45

  18. #18
    Sacramento StatIdaho
    CFB· ESPN+Down to the wire
    C
    42/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings15/25
    Comeback0/20
    Decided late11/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 60 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 42

  19. #19
    Colorado StatMTSU
    CFB· ESPN+Back and forth
    C
    37/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension12/30
    Swings17/25
    Comeback13/20
    Decided late1/15
    Back-and-forth10/10

    Drama 52 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 37

  20. #20
    East Texas A&MatOld Dominion
    CFB· ESPN+
    D
    33/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension27/30
    Swings9/25
    Comeback0/20
    Decided late8/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 47 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 33

  21. #21
    W MichiganatToledo
    CFB· ESPN+Back and forth
    D
    33/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension4/30
    Swings21/25
    Comeback10/20
    Decided late2/15
    Back-and-forth10/10

    Drama 47 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 33

  22. #22
    Western KYatTroy
    CFB· ESPNU
    D
    32/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension13/30
    Swings16/25
    Comeback6/20
    Decided late2/15
    Back-and-forth8/10

    Drama 46 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 32

  23. #23
    NevadaatTexas St
    CFB· ESPN+Big comeback
    D
    31/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension4/30
    Swings23/25
    Comeback15/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 44 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 31

  24. #24
    Oregon StatWashington St
    CFB· Fox
    D
    30/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension12/30
    Swings14/25
    Comeback6/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth0/10

    Drama 32 × pre-game weight 0.95 (pre-game Watchability 90, estimated) = 30

  25. #25
    RiceatSouth Florida
    CFB· ESPNUBack and forth
    D
    28/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension1/30
    Swings20/25
    Comeback9/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth10/10

    Drama 40 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 28

  26. #26
    Virginia TechatMarshall
    CFB· ESPN2
    D
    27/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension18/30
    Swings13/25
    Comeback3/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 39 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 27

  27. #27
    CoyotesatKings
    NHL· NHLPP|ESPN+/NHL Net
    D
    25/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension17/30
    Swings12/25
    Comeback1/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 34 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 25

  28. #28
    BYUatKansas
    CFB· ESPN
    D
    23/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension7/30
    Swings15/25
    Comeback4/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth8/10

    Drama 33 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 23

  29. #29
    MemphisatMissouri
    CFB· ESPNU
    D
    23/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension8/30
    Swings15/25
    Comeback3/20
    Decided late1/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 33 × pre-game weight 0.70 (pre-game Watchability 40, estimated) = 23

  30. #30
    Ole MissatAlabama
    CFB· CBSOne-sided
    D
    21/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension3/30
    Swings13/25
    Comeback2/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 22 × pre-game weight 0.95 (pre-game Watchability 90, estimated) = 21

Ranked from each game's win probability as it was played (ESPN's for football and basketball; ours, from the goals, for hockey): how in doubt it was near the end, how far the winner came back from, how late it was decided, how big its momentum swings were and how often a team erased a deficit, with a bonus for overtime. That drama is then weighted by how good a matchup it was going in (its pre-game Watchability score), so a thriller between top teams ranks above an equally wild game between minor ones.