Worth the replay?

Sunday, September 18's games ranked by how good they turned out to be: late drama, comebacks, lead swaps and overtime. No scores, no winners, so you can decide what to watch without spoilers. (The highlights links go to YouTube, where video titles may show the score.)

Best games of the season →

Get the weekend's best games every Friday. Free, one email a week.

  1. #1
    CardinalsatRaiders
    NFL· CBS· Highlights ↗OvertimeDown to the wireBig comeback
    A
    75/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings25/25
    Comeback20/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth5/10
    Overtime+8

    Drama 100 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 75

  2. #2
    DolphinsatRavens
    NFL· CBS· Highlights ↗Down to the wireBig comeback
    B+
    73/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings25/25
    Comeback20/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth8/10

    Drama 97 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 73

  3. #3
    JetsatBrowns
    NFL· CBS· Highlights ↗Down to the wireBig comebackBack and forth
    B+
    71/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings20/25
    Comeback20/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth10/10

    Drama 95 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 71

  4. #4
    BengalsatCowboys
    NFL· CBS· Highlights ↗Down to the wire
    B
    62/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings21/25
    Comeback13/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 82 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 62

  5. #5
    PanthersatGiants
    NFL· Fox· Highlights ↗Down to the wire
    B
    60/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings18/25
    Comeback11/20
    Decided late14/15
    Back-and-forth8/10

    Drama 80 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 60

  6. #6
    TexansatBroncos
    NFL· CBS· Highlights ↗Back and forth
    C+
    49/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension29/30
    Swings16/25
    Comeback4/20
    Decided late8/15
    Back-and-forth10/10

    Drama 66 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 49

  7. #7
    PatriotsatSteelers
    NFL· CBS· Highlights ↗
    C
    43/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings12/25
    Comeback1/20
    Decided late12/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 57 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 43

  8. #8
    FalconsatRams
    NFL· Fox· Highlights ↗
    C
    42/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings12/25
    Comeback0/20
    Decided late15/15
    Back-and-forth0/10

    Drama 57 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 42

  9. #9
    BuccaneersatSaints
    NFL· Fox· Highlights ↗Down to the wire
    C
    41/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension30/30
    Swings13/25
    Comeback3/20
    Decided late5/15
    Back-and-forth3/10

    Drama 54 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 41

  10. #10
    CommandersatLions
    NFL· Fox· Highlights ↗
    D
    21/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension11/30
    Swings13/25
    Comeback5/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth0/10

    Drama 28 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 21

  11. #11
    BearsatPackers
    NFL· NBC· Highlights ↗One-sided
    D
    10/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension5/30
    Swings3/25
    Comeback0/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth5/10

    Drama 13 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 10

  12. #12
    ColtsatJaguars
    NFL· CBS· Highlights ↗One-sided
    D
    9/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension0/30
    Swings8/25
    Comeback4/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth0/10

    Drama 12 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 9

  13. #13
    Seahawksat49ers
    NFL· Fox· Highlights ↗One-sided
    D
    4/100
    ▸ Why this grade
    Late tension3/30
    Swings3/25
    Comeback0/20
    Decided late0/15
    Back-and-forth0/10

    Drama 6 × pre-game weight 0.75 (pre-game Watchability 50, estimated) = 4

Ranked from each game's win probability as it was played (ESPN's for football and basketball; ours, from the goals, for hockey): how in doubt it was near the end, how far the winner came back from, how late it was decided, how big its momentum swings were and how often a team erased a deficit, with a bonus for overtime. That drama is then weighted by how good a matchup it was going in (its pre-game Watchability score), so a thriller between top teams ranks above an equally wild game between minor ones.